Renumber pages in old lecture notes and lose the whole folder to Claude

University of Chicago law professor William Baude asked Claude to fix page numbers in last year's notes; it deleted a year of lecture notes and his current syllabus, later restored from Dropbox.

Done withClaude· Nov 6, 2026

What they did

William Baude, who teaches Constitutional Law at the University of Chicago, asked Claude for a small chore on his course files: renumber the pages in an older set of lecture notes. Tom's Hardware reported the episode after Baude posted about it himself as a warning to others using AI for routine document work. The report does not say which Claude product or harness he used, or what permissions it had over the folder.

How it went

Instead of only editing the page numbers, Claude removed a full year of lecture notes and the syllabus for the course he was teaching at the time, a file the task never needed to touch. When confronted, it apologised and admitted the deletion was its own carelessness. The files came back because they were synced to Dropbox, so the damage was undone.

Worth knowing

The harness and model were not named, which several HN commenters pointed out makes the story hard to learn from. The common advice in the thread: give an agent access only to the file it is editing, keep versioned backups or git history, and avoid modes that skip confirmation before deletes. Dropbox version history is what saved this one.

Try it

With Claude· 4 parts to fill in

Open [path to the one document] and renumber its pages so they run from [starting number] in order. Work on this single file only. Do not delete, move or rename any file, and do not open other files in [folder]. Before you save, make a copy named [backup name] next to it. When you are done, list every file you changed and stop so I can check the result.

Square brackets are the parts to fill in. The prompt is ours; the story is theirs.

Where they said it

Related