Paint a tonalist oil study stroke by stroke through an MCP easel

A studio had Claude Opus 5.5 and Gemini 4 Hydrogen paint the same harbour scene in its oil engine via MCP brush calls only. Opus kept 36,700 strokes; Gemini was 10 minutes faster and far cheaper.

Done withClaudeGemini· Nov 14, 2026

What they did

MozoleStudio, posting on r/GeminiAI, is building Pochade, an unreleased engine that simulates physical oil paint and exposes it to models as an MCP easel. There is no image model and no pixel access underneath: a model can only load brushes, mix from 14 paint tubes on a palette, lay strokes or knife marks on an 800 by 600 canvas, look at the surface under raking light and rewind its own stroke journal. As a stress test the team gave Claude Opus 5.5 and Gemini 4 Hydrogen, both at their highest reasoning setting, the same brief: a tonalist plein-air study of a harbour gate at dusk. Each ran alone in a sandbox with no stroke limit and no other tools, at the same time. Afterwards the team reopened both sessions read-only and asked each model what got in its way.

How it went

Both painted on their own for 45 to 55 minutes. Opus took 55m 49s, kept 36,700 strokes and threw away about 46,600 more across some 15 rewound passes, and used 81% of a five-hour quota window. The team judged its arch depth and overall unity stronger, though upper wall corners came out flat and the paint was crusty everywhere. Gemini finished in 45m 53s with no tool errors, used roughly 60% less estimated compute, and painted richer water and sharper knife highlights, but left blocky, striped outer stonework. In the comments many readers preferred Gemini's picture. Both models hit a silent bug where an empty paint pile smeared thin marks instead of raising an error.

Worth knowing

The engine is the poster's own and is not public yet, so nobody else can rerun the test; they say it will be released under the AGPL. The harness around each model was not named. Opus admitted it sampled colours by running an image library on its own snapshots, which the rules did not forbid but readers should know. Which picture is better was disputed in the thread.

Try it

With Claude· 5 parts to fill in

You have an MCP painting tool at [my painting MCP server] that only accepts brush, palette and stroke calls. Paint [subject, for example a harbour gate at dusk] as a [style, for example tonalist plein-air oil study] on a [width x height] canvas. Plan the work in sittings: block in the big value masses first, then refine edges, then add highlights. After each sitting, view the canvas, write me a short note on what works and what does not, and rewind any pass that made it worse. Do not draw pixels directly or use any image generator. Check paint levels before every stroke batch and remix when a pile runs low. Stop after [number] sittings or when I say the study is done, then list every tool error or surprise you hit.

Square brackets are the parts to fill in. The prompt is ours; the story is theirs.

Where they said it

Related